R1m 'wasted' over Auction Alliance

The National Consumer Commission, established to protect consumers, has run up a R1-million legal bill in its failed efforts to get to the bottom of allegations around the controversial auction house Auction Alliance - money that will ultimately be paid from consumers' taxes.

That's according to Auction Alliance attorney Alan Smiedt, who said the company was owed more than R1m in legal fees by the beleaguered commission. And that sum would have been higher if Auction Alliance had persisted with its court application against the commission - wanting to have a summons that was issued to former company chief executive Rael Levitt reviewed and set aside.

The application, which was filed in the Western Cape High Court in August, related to another summons the commission had issued - for Levitt to appear in order to answer allegations relating to the sale of two properties - a plush residence in Hyde Park in Joburg, and the farm Doornkraal, in Pretoria.

The properties were sold last year, before the Quoin Rock wine estate auction and the fake bidding which blew the lid off the Auction Alliance practice.

The summons was issued in July, with Levitt asked to appear before the commission on August 16. However, shortly before that, Levitt and Auction Alliance approached the court to ask that the summons be set aside.

They argued that it was the product of an investigation which was "irregularly and unconstitutionally" initiated.

In addition, Levitt claimed there were defects with the summons, including the fact that it cited a section of the Consumer Protection Act which did not exist. He also attached a controversial secret report compiled by the National Consumer Tribunal, in which it lambasted the commission's handling of investigations into consumer complaints.

Smiedt wrote to the commission and its then-commissioner Mamodupi Mohlala-Mulaudzi to query not only that summons, but also summonses issued in respect of two other complaints against the company before the commission.

When he received no response, he took the legal route.

Eventually, days before the case was scheduled to be heard, Auction Alliance withdrew the application.

Smiedt told Weekend Argus this week the application was withdrawn after the commission agreed to drop the summonses if "we don't ask for a cost order against them".

This meant the commission could issue new summonses, but he said he doubted it would do so.

Smiedt also confirmed that the Hawks were still investigating the Quoin Rock scandal.
Asked to comment, the acting consumer commissioner Ebrahim Mohamed confirmed this did not mean other summonses could not be issued. The commission was assessing all cases to decide the best way forward.

Mohamed added that it would be premature to say whether another summons would be issued.

(Weekend Argus - Sunday Edition)

  Comment on this Article

  Please login to post comments

Post to my facebook wall
Characters remaining

    Latest Property News
    • 16 Mar 2018
      Strange as it may seem, there is a stock shortage looming now in the luxury sector of the Johannesburg property market, because astute buyers have for the past few months been hurrying to snap up high-end homes being offered at excellent prices.
    • 16 Mar 2018
      No one likes having to claim but having insurance for your household contents is vital, and at the start of a new financial year, homeowners either applying for new household insurance or revising their existing insurance should take a comprehensive inventory of their possessions and keep track of the total value.
    • 15 Mar 2018
      First-time buyers typically need to save for at least three years to afford the deposit on a home, and the VAT and fuel price increases announced in this year’s budget are going to make it even more difficult for them to reach that goal.
    • 15 Mar 2018
      Sea Point shows how developers use these organisations to advance their own interests
    • 15 Mar 2018
      As the rand strengthens against other major currencies, the prospect of investing in properties abroad is an increasingly appealing option for South African investors. Several factors, local and international, are sending a clear message: now is the time.
    • 14 Mar 2018
      Selling a property is never easy. Subtle details – from mismatched scatter cushions, to an unswept kitchen – can spell the difference between a potential buyer making an offer, or scratching your property off their list altogether. As much as you would love to be around to hear the passing comments as buyers amble through your abode, by choosing to remain at home during a showing, you set yourself at risk of becoming exactly that “subtle detail” that gets in the way of an offer.
    • 14 Mar 2018
      Home design mirrors the world around us and the phenomena of global warming, fossil fuel depletion and natural resource scarcity have created a revolution in architectural concepts and design.
    • 13 Mar 2018
      It has long been a foregone conclusion that towns where markets are driven largely by the demand for holiday homes will always perform below the national average during subdued economic times, but a report released by FNB last month has revealed that this is no longer the case.
    Subscribe to the MyProperty Newsletter

    Last Name  
    Email Address  
    Email Frequency
    Share this Page

    For Sale Property
    Rental Property
    More Options
    Connect with us