select
|

Concourt judgment a big win for real estate

Today’s ruling by the Constitutional Court means that new home owners will no longer have to worry about being held liable for historical debt incurred by previous owners, and having their municipal services cut off as a result, or possibly even having their property attached and sold in execution.
 
So says Berry Everitt, CEO of the Chas Everitt International property group, who notes that the judgment brings to an end a long period of confusion “and no little controversy” since judgment was given in 2013 in the Gauteng High Court case Mathabathe vs Municipality of Tshwane, which concerned the process of obtaining and lodging a municipal clearance certificate.
 
“In terms of Section 118(1) of the Municipal Systems Act, conveyancers are obliged to obtain such clearance certificates before properties can be transferred to new owners, in order to ensure that any rates and utility charges to the local authority by the property seller have been paid up to date.
 
“However, the Act in fact only stipulates that the municipality must issue the certificate if the outstanding debt for the two years immediately preceding the date of sale has been paid in full, and in the above case the court ruled that if there was debt older than that (historical debt), the property could be transferred to the new owner but the seller would remain indebted to the municipality for historical debt.”
 
All would have been fine at that point, he says, except for the fact that Section 118(3) of the Act stipulates that all municipal debt (including the historical debt) is actually “a charge upon the property”, rather than on a person – which led the court to also rule that the municipality would therefore have a lien (statutory tacit hypothec) over the property for the payment of the historical debt – and that this lien would not be extinguished when the property was transferred to a new owner.
 
“The effect of this, in legal language, was seemingly that a municipality which wanted to ‘perfect its lien’ could thus attach the property from the new owner and sell it on auction to settle the previous owner’s historical debt. And in fact some municipalities did start trying to use this judgment to try to collect historical debt from new owners. Some even went so far as to refuse to open utility accounts in the name of new owners until they had settled the previous owners’ historical debt.”
 
Everitt says this has obviously created a major worry and frustration for property buyers, and for the real estate industry as a whole, and that the situation was only slightly improved by the 2014 judgment in the case of PJ Mitchell v City of Tshwane Metropolitan Authority, when the same court ruled that a municipality’s lien over a property had been extinguished by a sale in execution and that the new owner should be granted a clean title.
 
“In that case, the court did also rule that a municipality cannot refuse to provide services to a new owner on the grounds that there is an historical debt that has not been paid – but it remained to be decided what should happen when a property is not sold in execution but, as is usually the case, in terms of an agreement between buyer and seller.
 
“And this is exactly what today’s ruling by the Constitutional Court makes clear. The unanimous judgment, which was handed down by Justice Edwin Cameron, is that Section 118(3) of the Municipal Systems Act is capable of 


  Comment on this Article

  Please login to post comments

Post to my facebook wall
  
2000
Characters remaining


    Latest Property News
    • 18 May 2018
      Home improvements are a great way to add value to your property, but not all of us have bottomless pockets for a full-on renovation. Lucky for us, there are plenty of affordable DIYs that can spruce things up over a free weekend.
    • 18 May 2018
      The need for large office spaces is slowly eroding as more and more employers choose to allow their staff to work remotely. As a result, the home business model has grown in popularity, with many new entrepreneurs choosing to start their business from home rather than in a business district. But, what are the legal implications of operating a business in a residential area?
    • 18 May 2018
      Proxi Smart Services Pty Ltd, a company that deals with the day to day administration of property transfers while the conveyancer attorneys perform the legal side of transfers, lost its bid for the court to allow them to do business in this regard.
    • 17 May 2018
      If you’re a first time buyer, then you are probably only just beginning to realize how expensive furniture can be. That three-piece lounge suite you’ve had on your “Dream Home” inspiration board probably seems like nothing but an unrealistic fantasy to you now. But, a little bit of financial discipline mixed with a dash of smart shopping can go a long way towards helping you furnish your fantasy.
    • 17 May 2018
      In recent years the demand for sectional title apartments – both for rent and to purchase - in Rivonia, which is considered to be one of the most affluent residential and suburbs in Johannesburg, has been incredibly strong.
    • 16 May 2018
      Nestled in the Cape winelands, Franschhoek boasts sumptuous offerings from local food artisans and manufacturers, with a recent addition – craft beer! Visitors to this famed gourmet region can now enjoy Franschhoek Beer Co’s premium craft beer in the middle of wine country, thanks to the brewery’s new restaurant, Tap | Eat.
    • 16 May 2018
      You have found your dream home, your offer was accepted and your bond approved, but now what?
    • 16 May 2018
      Solar energy has exploded over the last decade with the cost of solar panels decreasing, making solar more affordable than ever. Many homeowners have already invested in this to make their homes more environmentally friendly and sustainable, but if you are still investigating the options available to you, this article could assist you in taking that final step towards sustainable living.
        
    X
    Subscribe to the MyProperty Newsletter

    Name  
    Last Name  
    Email Address  
    Email Frequency
    select
    X
    Share this Page

       
    For Sale Property
    Rental Property
    More Options
    About
    Connect with us
    FEEDBACK