Smaller is better, but even the smaller home market shows signs of slowing

(Article by John Loos - household and property sector strategist at FNB Home Loans)

We have for some time been saying that smaller is better when it comes to home buying, but that doesn’t mean the smaller home market isn’t slowing down.

All of the factors we have periodically claimed are more in favour of small home buying remain relevant: the economic environment remains weak, causing weak household income growth, and interest rates have risen mildly in recent years.

Effective personal tax rates continue to rise, and municipal rates and tariff increases outpace general inflation. And, of course, there is the sliding scale for transfer duties, putting more expensing homes, which are on average larger, into higher transfer duty brackets. So, not surprisingly, the smaller home market continued to outperform the medium and large-sized segments in the third quarter.

However, all of this does not prevent the smaller-sized market from going into a slowdown too, and indeed, while it remains the relative best performer of the three size segments, it has shown signs of slowing of late.

In our FNB House Price Indices, the three size categories are the small homes of 20 to 80m2, medium homes of 80 to 230m2, and the large homes of 230 to 800m2.

The house price inflation rates for the three categories continue to differ noticeably. The small home category’s average price is R616 180 and price inflation was the highest of the three segments, at 8.1 percent  year-on-year in the third quarter. However, this represents a slowing in growth from the previous quarter’s revised rate of 11.7 percent and the first quarter’s high of 11.9 percent.

Next was the medium home category with an average price of R1.111m and 5.8 percent year-on-year price inflation, which reflects a slight de-celeration from 6.6 percent in the second quarter and 7.5 percent in the first quarter.

The large home category with an average price of R1.958m may be stabilising a bit at very weak levels, having seen its inflation rate accelerate mildly from 1 percent year-on-year in the first quarter to 3 percent by the third quarter. At such a low price inflation rate, however, we cannot yet call this a strengthening, as the 3 percent rate remains significantly negative in real terms, when adjusting for general inflation, as measured by the CPI (Consumer Price Index), of nearer to 6 percent.

The small home category has “out-inflated” the other two categories for most of the time from 2010. And if one evaluates the performance of the three size categories’ price indices since even further back from the first quarter of 2001, a more than 15 year period, we see that the small segment has outperformed the other two on a cumulative inflation basis.

The smaller house price index has inflated by 372.9 percent since the first quarter of 2001. The medium house index is not too far behind with 351.9 percent cumulative inflation over the same period. But the large home segment has underperformed by a significant margin, especially since around 2011, cumulatively inflating by a significantly lesser 285.3 percent since early-2001.

  Comment on this Article

  Please login to post comments

Post to my facebook wall
Characters remaining

    Latest Property News
    • 24 May 2018
      Most real estate professionals agree that 2017 was one the toughest years to date; an eminently challenging 12 months that subdued even the strongest markets - including the country’s economic powerhouse of Sandton.
    • 24 May 2018
      These are uncertain and challenging times for the real estate industry, but the non-profit organisation Rebosa is fighting for their interests and finding pragmatic solutions to industry issues such as the urgent need to fast-track transformation says Richard Gray, Rebosa chairman.
    • 24 May 2018
      The decision to invest in property isn’t one that’s taken lightly, or dealt with flippantly. The same should ring true when deciding on an estate agent partner to handle the letting out of your property.
    • 23 May 2018
      Homeowners who are thinking of selling and “trading up” to a bigger or a better home had better be quick now if they want to get the best deal.
    • 23 May 2018
      The new Loftus Park development in Arcadia is really going to boost the demand for homes and rental accommodation close by and the neighbouring suburb of Sunnyside, says Gerhard Kotzé, MD of estate agency group RealNet Holdings.
    • 23 May 2018
      The importance of correctly pricing a property for sale is more imperative than ever. This is according to Debbie Justus-Ferns, divisional manager of Renprop Residential Sales, who says that despite this crucial selling fact being emphasised so often, in the current market, many sellers are still expecting unrealistic prices for their homes which is having a negative impact on the ultimate sale price.
    • 22 May 2018
      Extreme weather appears to be the new normal, evident by the volume of insurance-related disputes reaching the industry watchdog’s desk. To avoid a situation in which your insurer refuses to pay up, you should proactively ensure that your home is well-maintained and ready for whatever winter has in store.
    • 22 May 2018
      As the impact of technology on the real estate industry becomes more significant, it is clear that there is a need for an objective look at not only traditional real estate models but also online and other alternative low-commission real estate agencies, to examine what they offer and what their impact might be.
    Subscribe to the MyProperty Newsletter

    Last Name  
    Email Address  
    Email Frequency
    Share this Page

    For Sale Property
    Rental Property
    More Options
    Connect with us