Historical debts - new landmark ruling

In a landmark decision in the Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, municipalities cannot hold new property owners responsible for the historic debt for municipal services of previous owners. 

The Pretoria News reported that attorney Gary Ross had said that the decision would have far-reaching consequences for many residential and business property owners, the property industry as well as municipalities themselves. Adding that the judgment would not only save unknowing property buyers from being forced to pay former owners' old debts to have services reconnected, it would also force the municipalities themselves to make work of collecting debt and not expect new owners to finance the debt.

Judge Dawie Fourie declared the provisions of section 118(3) of the Local Government Municipal Systems Act, which provides for this, constitutionally invalid to the extent only that the security provision, "a charge upon the property", survives transfer of ownership into the name of a new or subsequent owner who is not a debtor of the municipality with regard to municipal debts incurred prior to such transfer.

"Tshwane and Ekurhuleni municipalities were ordered to render municipal services where no debt exists in respect of municipal services between the municipalities and the new owners.

"The municipalities were restrained from claiming payment of outstanding amounts from new owners where they have no debt relationship with the municipality concerned in respect of municipal rates, taxes and charges," Judge Fourie said.

Ross said: "The practice by municipalities in holding new owners liable for the payment of historical debts of previous owners or tenants of previous owners was declared unlawful and invalid and this is great news all round."

In a shock move earlier this year, the Supreme Court of Appeal ruled that new property owners could be held liable for historic debts dating back 30 years.

However, the judge stated that he had ruled only on the legality of S189 and not on the constitutional implications of the by-law. This finding was based on the court's interpretation of section 118 as interpreted against the backdrop of the South African common law relating to hypothecs, he said.

Ross said the judge made it very clear at the time that his judgment did not consider constitutional aspects. Five parties, all of whom are having similar problems with new owners not being given services, got together for yesterday's case.

  Comment on this Article

  Please login to post comments

Post to my facebook wall
Characters remaining

    Latest Property News
    • 19 Mar 2018
      If a landlord opts to use a managing agent for the rental of his or her property, the inspection process can be easier as the agent is not emotionally involved and will certainly have concluded an in-depth inspection report in the interests of all parties.
    • 19 Mar 2018
      We all wish we could have the cheat sheet for selling a property – a simple Ctrl+Shift+C code that will magically secure an offer on your home in an instant. Though it is not possible to provide you with this cheat code (sadly, reality does not come with such perks), it is possible to provide you with a list of the most common blunders some of your neighbours have committed in their efforts to sell their homes
    • 19 Mar 2018
      Although property technology is now widely accepted as an established trend, especially in the international real estate arena, the industry has been cautious to advance and smaller markets like South Africa are still hesitantly dipping their toes in the water.
    • 16 Mar 2018
      Strange as it may seem, there is a stock shortage looming now in the luxury sector of the Johannesburg property market, because astute buyers have for the past few months been hurrying to snap up high-end homes being offered at excellent prices.
    • 16 Mar 2018
      No one likes having to claim but having insurance for your household contents is vital, and at the start of a new financial year, homeowners either applying for new household insurance or revising their existing insurance should take a comprehensive inventory of their possessions and keep track of the total value.
    • 15 Mar 2018
      First-time buyers typically need to save for at least three years to afford the deposit on a home, and the VAT and fuel price increases announced in this year’s budget are going to make it even more difficult for them to reach that goal.
    • 15 Mar 2018
      Sea Point shows how developers use these organisations to advance their own interests
    • 15 Mar 2018
      As the rand strengthens against other major currencies, the prospect of investing in properties abroad is an increasingly appealing option for South African investors. Several factors, local and international, are sending a clear message: now is the time.
    Subscribe to the MyProperty Newsletter

    Last Name  
    Email Address  
    Email Frequency
    Share this Page

    For Sale Property
    Rental Property
    More Options
    Connect with us