Lease agreements – holding over and the risk of prescription

(Article by Justine Krige*)

Litigation over lease agreements is all too common in South Africa. It often ensues when tenants refuse to vacate leased premises, despite outstanding rental payments and the subsequent cancellation of the lease agreement by the landlord.

In SA law landlords have a three year period in which to institute a claim against a tenant for any amounts owing (including damages and outstanding rental payments). After that period the landlord’s claim prescribes, that is, it is no longer enforceable. The crucial question is this: From which date does prescription start running, particularly in cases where a tenant remains in occupation of leased premises, despite the cancellation of the lease agreement? An additional layer of complexity arises in cases where the tenant remains in occupation of the leased premises in spite of it having been cancelled and continues to pay rental to the landlord. How does this affect prescription?

The issue of Monyetla Property Holdings v IMM Graduate School of Marketing was recently considered by the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in Monyetla Property Holdings v IMM Graduate School of Marketing (20023/2014) [2015] ZASCA 32 (25 March 2015). In Monyetla, the SCA dealt with the principle that there is a distinction between the concept of a debt “arising” and a debt “becoming due” and that a debt is only due, owing or payable for purposes of prescription, “when the entire set of facts which the creditor must prove to succeed with his claim against the debtor is in place: when everything has happened which would entitle the creditor to institute action”.

In the case of a lease agreement, the general rule is that where a party breaches the agreement, the other party is entitled to claim damages to place it in the position that it would have been had the other party properly and timeously performed its obligations. Where the landlord has cancelled the lease agreement as a result of the non-performance of the tenant, damages are calculated based on the rental that would have been paid by the tenant to the landlord, had the lease agreement run its full term, less any amounts received (subject of course to the landlord taking steps to mitigate the loss by, for example, trying to get another tenant).

Importantly, in Monyetla the SCA held that the prescription period runs from the date of cancellation of the lease agreement despite the fact that a tenant remains in occupation of the leased premises and continues to pay rental under a clause in the lease agreement that obliges it to do so if the cancellation is disputed. In this regard, the SCA held that “continued occupation of the premises is irrelevant to a claim for damages arising from cancelling a lease due to the tenant’s breach”.

Lease agreements often contain a “holding over” clause, that is, a provision that says that if the landlord cancels the lease agreement, and the tenant disputes the right to cancel and remains in occupation of the property, the tenant will, pending the determination of that dispute by litigation or otherwise, continue to pay to the landlord an amount equivalent to the monthly rental. What Monyetla makes clear is that landlords have three years from the date of cancellation of the lease agreement to claim damages, not three years from the date on which the tenant stops paying.

The lesson in Monyetla is that landlords must be mindful that the start of the prescription period for a damages claim is the date of the cancellation of the lease agreement, and that prescription continues to run from this date despite the fact that the tenant may remain in occupation of the premises, in some cases even paying rental (or a reduced rental) while they remain in occupation. So landlords must sue tenants as soon as possible after they have cancelled the agreement.

*Justine Krige is a senior associate in the corporate and commercial practice at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr.

  Comment on this Article

  Please login to post comments

Post to my facebook wall
Characters remaining

    Latest Property News
    • 20 Feb 2018
      Owning a home is a milestone that most South Africans aspire to. Becoming a homeowner is a step towards growing personal wealth and owning an asset that appreciates in value over time, provided of course that the correct principles are applied during the buying stage of the process, says Adrian Goslett, Regional Director and CEO of RE/MAX of Southern Africa.
    • 20 Feb 2018
      The suburb of Greenstone in Johannesburg east came to be over the last two decades. “In the beginning, it was literally just a hill with not so much as a shopping centre,” says Michael Levy, Property Consultant at Jawitz Properties Bedfordview. Today it has plenty shopping facilities and is fully built, boasting high-density, upmarket housing and residential estates, though still has a few pockets poised for commercial development.
    • 20 Feb 2018
      A major shift in the ageing paradigm has precipitated an equally dramatic transformation in the retirement sector, with modern accommodation options worlds away from the conventional model.
    • 19 Feb 2018
      Possibly one of the biggest sources of contention between landlords and tenants surrounds the rental deposit. “Most tenants rely on getting their rental deposits back when moving, so that they can use it to pay a deposit on their new home. Having it withheld or even having large amounts deducted can lead to a lot of distress,” explains Bruce Swain, CEO of Leapfrog Property Group.
    • 19 Feb 2018
      Situated approximately halfway between Johannesburg and Pretoria, Midrand was established in 1981 and forms part of the City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality. It has become one of the major business hubs in the country with major pharmaceutical, textile, telecommunication and motoring giants situated within its boundaries.
    • 19 Feb 2018
      The PayProp Rental Index Annual Review of 2017 shows that the rental market suffered from much volatility during the year. It kicked off with rental growth spiking in January with weighted year-on-year growth (YoY) growth peaking at 8.3% before dropping to 6.34% in July, dipping down to less than 5% in November and then experiencing a slight uptick at 5.75% in December.
    • 19 Feb 2018
      While most homes in cluster complexes, estates and other gated communities come with at least one garage or carport, residents would often like additional permanent parking or storage areas for things like trailers, bikes, boats and caravans.
    • 16 Feb 2018
      Whether you own a property in a sectional title complex or are looking to invest in one, the financial standing of the body corporate is the single most important thing that can affect your investment or your buying decision.
    Subscribe to the MyProperty Newsletter

    Last Name  
    Email Address  
    Email Frequency
    Share this Page

    For Sale Property
    Rental Property
    More Options
    Connect with us